Hogwarts' famous Platform 9 3/4 from the train station

Storytelling Themes That Are Brand Magic

No matter the distribution, storytelling remains the most powerful way to connect with your audience. Whether you’re a brand or a business leader, storytelling isn’t just a marketing tactic. It’s connecting people with emotion and, when done right, can be very effective. Did you know —

  • 92% of consumers prefer ads that feel like stories.
  • People are 22 times more likely to remember a fact when presented in a story.
  • 55% of people who love a brand’s story are more likely to be loyal.

There’s a reason why certain movies and books become timeless classics – they follow a formula that resonates. These themes can be carried over as a framework for storytelling in your marketing. Here are a few classic narratives and how to make them relevant for your brand:

The Comeback

 Why it works: Rocky. Cinderella Man. Million Dollar Baby. Going beyond the boxing ring, everyone loves a comeback story. Demonstrating resilience and transformation as a brand inspires hope and shows that growth is possible, even in the face of failure.

How to use it:

  • Be honest about struggles as a company and tell the story of how your business overcame challenges.
  • Highlight customer stories where your product helped them with a challenge.
  • Use before-and-after narratives to demonstrate transformation.

The Hero’s Journey

Why it works: Whether you are thinking of the boy who lived or everyone’s favorite Jedi, the classic narrative arc (challenge → struggle → triumph) mirrors the human experience. It’s incredibly relatable and emotionally satisfying.

How to use it:

  • Tell the story of your founder’s journey.
  • Frame your customer as the hero, with your brand as the guide.
  • Use this arc in product launches or rebrands.

David vs. Goliath

Why it works:  Wax on, wax off. Underdog stories are compelling because they challenge the status quo. They evoke empathy and rally support.

How to use it:

  • Position your brand as the challenger in a crowded market.
  • Share how you’re disrupting an outdated industry.
  • Highlight your unique approach or values that set you apart.

The “Aha!” Moment

Why it works: When my daughter was three, we watched Frozen more times than I can count, and I will forever love Elsa’s ‘aha’ moment where she finally embraces who she is meant to be. “Aha!” moments are exciting and contagious. They show innovation, curiosity, and the spark of creativity.

How to use it:

  • Share the moment your product/service idea was born.
  • Highlight customer discoveries—new ways they use your product or service.
  • Use these stories to introduce new features or insights.

“Feeling” Stories Makes them Memorable

The best stories aren’t just told…they’re felt. By weaving these themes into your content, you create narratives that don’t just inform but also inspire. Whether you’re launching a campaign or building your brand voice, these storytelling frameworks can help you connect to your audience on a much deeper level.

And thank you for your patience with all my pop culture references. What’s your favorite story and why is it impactful?

Rebecca Wrenn

Senior Account Director

Rebecca joined Sweeney in 2014 as an account executive and subsequently shifted roles in 2016 to support the agency leadership team in successfully establishing a highly effective, full-service creative capability, including branding, design, and video production services. In 2020, she pivoted once again to take on a senior account leadership role while simultaneously leading agency operations. With nearly a decade of strategic marketing, communications and creative experience, Rebecca currently directs several agency account teams, while also managing critical aspects of agency’s operations. Her deep knowledge of the account management process and her high creative aptitude are an exceptional benefit to the agency and its clients.